Called In Sic

Loved the color of the decor, the "eagles' nest", and the pool. Everything worked perfectly.The only negative was the ants in the kitchen near the faucet and the bugs in the 3rd bathroom upstairs.

tywileng - Posted: 10/12/2025

Hi, Alicia, thanks for staying with Anna Maria Island Accommodations at Called In Sic! We’re so glad you loved the decor, the “eagle’s nest,” and the pool, it’s such a fun spot to relax and enjoy island life. We appreciate you letting us know about the pest issue so our team can address it right away. Hope to welcome you back to Anna Maria Island soon for another great stay!!

Prime Vacations staff

We had a wonderful time at this house. Loved the view from the rooftop while sipping our coffee. The proximity to Bean Point Beach was fantastic. Close to restaurants. Enjoyed the pool, hot tub and games. Comfortable beds. Our family of 4 had plenty of room to spread out and relax.

Jamie - Posted: 9/25/2025

Thank you for the thoughtful review, Jamie! We’re so glad your family enjoyed the home! Those rooftop coffee views and being near Bean Point are hard to beat. Happy to hear you loved the pool, hot tub, and space to relax. We’d love to host you again with Anna Maria Island Accommodations!!

Prime Vacations staff

This beach vacation home is awesome! The house has been completely renovated with beautiful floors, cabinets, bathrooms and outside areas. There are a ton of games and activities provided, a putt putt area on the side of the house, a beautiful pool and hot tub that is private from the neighbors due to all the palms lining the property and a second floor deck. The beds are comfortable with nice sheets, the shower has great water pressure and gets hot fast, the AC is easy to adjust and got so cold, so we slept like babies. There’s a spiral staircase that leads to a balcony with beautiful views, which my son loved! This house and the management team were great, we never felt like we were missing anything or that any detail was left out. We plan on staying here again in the future! Oh, and football games on the outside TV while relaxing in the pool was a big hit! Thanks again!

Katie - Posted: 9/15/2025

Thank you for such a wonderful review, Katie! We’re so glad you loved the renovated home, pool and hot tub, and all the fun extras like putt putt and the outdoor TV. It’s great to hear the home had everything your family needed, from comfy beds to that balcony view your son enjoyed. We’d be thrilled to welcome you back with Anna Maria Island Accommodations anytime!

Prime Vacations staff

The six of us stayed for four nights during spring break. The property had plenty of room and was in a quiet neighborhood. Very short walk to beach. There were stores, bars, and restaurants close enough to walk to. All in all it was a great trip and the house worked excellent for the six adults who were.

Jesse - Posted: 3/24/2025

Thank you for choosing us for your recent stay! Every review and every star you give us makes a huge difference to our success. If you enjoyed your stay, we'd love your 5-star review! We hope to host you again in the future!

Prime Vacations staff

House, hot tub and pool were great

Lizzie C. - Posted: 5/27/2024

Lizzie, we're thrilled to hear that you enjoyed your stay and that you found the house, hot tub, and pool to be great! Thank you for choosing our property, and we hope to welcome you back for another fantastic stay in the future! If there's anything we can do to make your next visit even more enjoyable, please don't hesitate to let us know.

Prime Vacations staff

This house was great for our family, 3 children. The downstairs suite was perfect for my father in law, who joined us as well! The kitchen was well stocked and we were easily able to prepare meals. The beds were comfortable and overall the house was beautiful and very comfortable! The pool area is amazing. Our kids couldn’t get enough! The garage was stocked full of fun toys and games. The outdoor shower was convenient and so nice! This house was perfect, exactly what we were looking for and such a treat for our family. I would recommend for younger kids, bring crocs or something like that for around the pool. The deck is slick when wet, but water shoes or crocs make that no issue at all!

Kellea M. - Posted: 5/14/2024

Thank you, Kellea, for the feedback! We are truly glad that the adults and littles of your family enjoyed the property! We cannot wait to see you all again !

Prime Vacations staff

Good location and great house

Sandra S. - Posted: 5/5/2024

Sandra, we're delighted to hear that you found our house to be in a good location and that you had a great stay! Thank you for choosing to stay with us, and we hope to welcome you back again soon for another fantastic experience. If there's anything else we can do to make your next visit even better, please don't hesitate to let us know.

Prime Vacations staff

We had a fabulous time! The pool and hot tub were perfect. The basketball hoop was a fun bonus in the pool area. A walk to bean point beach was on point! All of the beach amenities were provided from the house with a cart. Sunsets on the roof deck, golf carts we rented, shopping,etc. Loved it all! We'll be back.

Jacqueline P. - Posted: 4/28/2024

Jacqueline, thank you for sharing your experience! We're thrilled to hear that you had a fabulous time and enjoyed the pool, hot tub, and the basketball hoop. It sounds like you made the most of the amenities, from the beach cart to the sunsets on the roof deck. We're glad the location met your expectations and that you enjoyed the local activities like renting golf carts and shopping. We look forward to welcoming you back for another wonderful stay!

Prime Vacations staff

Overall, “Called in Sic” was exactly as advertised. Situated in a quiet neighborhood, one block from the beach, the location couldn’t have been better. The roof deck was off the charts. 360 degree view for miles. The house was pristinely clean when we arrived. Communication with the rental company was prompt and extremely attentive. The pool provided both adequate shade as well as sun filled spots to lounge. The garage area was awesome, and a favorite of the kids in our group. The outdoor TV/lounge area was a great spot to hang out at night. A couple minor critiques, the construction next door was unfortunate, but unavoidable from the renters standpoint. The weekdays we stayed were filled with hammers and loud music from the construction crew from about 10am thru 5pm, and was noticeable if you were on the roof deck our out by the pool. We drowned out most of the noise with our own speaker, but definitely a downfall of being on an area of the island that has construction. The first night we stayed, we were excited to fire up the grill, only to find out the propane tanks were both empty. We contacted the rental company via text and there were 2 tanks delivered before we woke up the next day. We had to change our plans from grilling hamburgers to using the stove, which proved difficult with only one frying pan provided. Overall, everything was outstanding. We will look to book the same week next year, when the construction next door will be finished. Location unmatched

Michael L. - Posted: 3/17/2024

Michael, thank you for your thorough and thoughtful review of "Called in Sic"! We're thrilled to hear that the property met your expectations and provided a fantastic experience overall. We're delighted that you found the location to be ideal, and that the roof deck, pool, garage area, and outdoor lounge added to your enjoyment. We sincerely apologize for the inconvenience caused by the nearby construction. While it's beyond our control, we understand how it can impact the overall experience, and we appreciate your understanding. We're glad to hear that our team responded promptly to your concerns about the empty propane tanks, and we're sorry for any inconvenience this caused. We'll certainly take your feedback about kitchen supplies into consideration for future improvements. We're grateful for your understanding and support, and we look forward to hosting you again. Thank you for choosing to stay with us, and we can't wait to welcome you back!

Prime Vacations staff

This house was perfect for a girls weekend away with family - plenty of room to spread out for 6 people. The pool was awesome - and we enjoyed the hot tub portion since we had cooler temps. 5 minute walk to a Bean Point beach entrance made for easy trips back and forth to the beach! Walk to town/trolley is ~15 minutes as well. The rooftop is such a great spot to relax with plenty of seating! Great communication with the property manager. We loved our stay at AMI and would rent here again!

Jessica S. - Posted: 2/7/2024

Thank you for sharing your experience, Jess! We're thrilled to hear that the house was perfect for your girls' weekend away with family and that there was plenty of room for everyone. It's fantastic that you enjoyed the pool and hot tub, especially with the cooler temperatures. The proximity to Bean Point beach entrance and town/trolley sounds ideal, and we're glad you found it convenient. The rooftop relaxation spot sounds wonderful! We appreciate your kind words about our communication and property management. We're delighted that you loved your stay at AMI and would be honored to have you stay here again in the future!

Prime Vacations staff

Great amenities, pool and hot tub hit the spot, and view wonderful. Communication with management was great.

Jeff R. - Posted: 12/21/2023

Thank you for taking the time to share your experience, Jeff. We are glad you enjoyed your stay and hope to welcome you back soon!

Prime Vacations staff

We had a wonderful 4-night stay at Called in Sic. Comfortable beds, lots of amenities, easy walk to the beach, great pool and hot tub. The outside and garage “playroom” set up is great for both kids and adults. We will definitely come back!

Tricia P. - Posted: 11/7/2023

Thank you for taking the time to share your wonderful experience, Tricia. We are glad you enjoyed your stay and hope to welcome you back soon!

Prime Vacations staff

Six 58+ year olds who have been friends since elementary school stayed at this property the first week in May. We absolutely loved the house. We hung out at the pool & patio area for a portion of every day! The ping pong table and games in the garage were an excellent bonus and the roof top patio was beautiful. The location was convenient, but we were glad to have rented a golf cart for the week to get around the island. The house was completely as promised and as pictured. When our internet service went out, it was fixed the very next day. Communication with the management company was responsive & timely. I hope to stay at this property again!

Sheila S., Eldridge, Iowa - Posted: 8/9/2023

Thank you for taking the time to share your wonderful experience with us. We are glad you enjoyed the home, location, and communication with our team. You were terrific guests, and we hope to welcome you back soon!

Prime Vacations staff

Spacious and updated with a great pool and spa. First time we have had an observation deck to see the bay and sunrise in the morning.

chad c. - Posted: 2/24/2023

Chad, thank you for taking the time to share your experience with us. We are glad you enjoyed your stay and hope to host you again!

Prime Vacations staff

It was what we were hoping for. The property and surroundings were idyllic and would highly recommend Anna Maria

Caroline T. - Posted: 12/30/2022

Caroline, thank you for taking the time to share your experience with us. We are glad you enjoyed your stay and hope to host you again sometime soon!

Prime Vacations staff

This property was amazing. Plenty of space for couples but also would have been great with kids too. We especially loved having the pool, and really enjoyed the view from the rooftop deck. The location is perfect with a very short walk or bike ride to multiple access points to the beach. We would definitely return to this wonderful location!

Sara T. - Posted: 10/25/2022

Sara, thank you for taking the time to share your experience with us. We are thrilled to hear you enjoyed the home, pool, and rooftop deck. You were wonderful guests, and we hope to host you again soon!

Prime Vacations staff

Wish we could have stayed longer.

Kris V. - Posted: 9/17/2022

Kris, thank you for taking the time to share your experience with us. We are happy to hear you enjoyed your stay, and we hope to host you again soon!

Prime Vacations staff

The house was fitting for our needs and the location was awesome! The partially covered pool was great for those of us who needed a break from the sun. The rental company was so helpful and took care of any concerns we had right away. The rooftop deck was my favorite part of the house because the views of the ocean and sunrise/sunsets were amazing. We watched dolphins swim by and lots of cool birds (including Quaker parrots) and even did some morning yoga overlooking the ocean. Great stay!

Karen W. - Posted: 6/21/2022

Karen, thank you for your 5-star review! Happy to hear you had a relaxing stay and enjoyed the pool and rooftop for sunsets. We appreciate all of your feedback and look forward to your return.

Prime Vacations staff

The location and the property were great.

Eugenia P., Arlington, TX USA - Posted: 6/11/2022

Thank you for your 5-star review, Eugenia! We are happy that you loved the home and the location. We hope to host you again soon!

Prime Vacations staff

Beautiful hot tub and pool oasis! Tastefully decorated spacious home, near beach and quaint area of the island. We’ll be back. Loved our family vacation here!

Kelley W. - Posted: 12/20/2020

Thank you for the great review Kelley! We are so glad to hear that you had a great vacation and look forward to having you stay with us again!

Prime Vacations staff

Great experience for my family. Just steps from the bay area and 50 yards from the North pointe...where you have a very clear view of the Gulf and Bay area. House is completely remodeled on the inside, pool area was very clean and relaxing. The roof top terrace is what my wife and I enjoyed the most. Watching the sunrise and sunset. Check in couldn't be any smoother. We rented a Golf cart for the week and the kids had a blast with that as well. The house came with paddle boards, kayaks, beach chairs, ping pong table and so much more. We will be back! Management team was great to work with...very simplistic process!

Brett L., Ft. Myers USA - Posted: 11/29/2020

Hi Brett! Thanks for the awesome review. Glad that you could enjoy the roof top deck. That is one of our favorite spots as well! We look forward to having you stay with us in the future!

Prime Vacations staff

Property was beautiful, home is nicely decorated and very pretty. Pool was great, upstairs deck gave a panoramic view of everything! Weather was fantastic, we’ll be back!

Therese P. - Posted: 11/18/2020

Thank you for the 5 stars Therese! Let us know when you are ready to call in Sic again. We would be more than happy to have you back!

Prime Vacations staff

Everything very easy. Nice place.

Rob K. - Posted: 11/1/2020

Thank you Rob! Glad you had a great trip!

Prime Vacations staff

The house was very clean with lost of space and amenities. Pool and spa under the deck was awesome. Close to the beach and plenty of places to eat. Perfect getaway!

RICHARD M., VALRICO, FL - Posted: 10/18/2020

We are so happy to hear you enjoyed our home! Thank you for the great feedback Richard!

Prime Vacations staff

We absolutely loved our stay at Called in Sic. The house was perfect for us with several bedrooms and baths, it was also very well stocked and exceptionally clean. The location is excellent! You can walk to Bean Point Beach and Rod and Reel Pier. The pool area is private and so very wonderful for all of us to hang together. The upper patio is the perfect spot for beautiful sunsets! The management company was wonderful! The morning we arrived, a storm had knocked out all cable and internet in the house. The management team tried very hard to have everything repaired that Saturday but it had to wait until Monday. Not a big deal, but my son had a zoom business meeting Monday morning. So, the management team brought equipment to the house to be sure he could log in. So awesome! We would love to stay in this house again and would rent from the management team as well.

Kimberly P. - Posted: 7/25/2020

Hi Kimberly, Thank you so much for the great review! We really appreciate your feedback and kind words. We look forward to having you stay with us again!

Prime Vacations staff

Experience was awesome the cleanliness and location of the property was great. The choice of both the bay and the gulf beaches was awesome. Loved the pool and the sunset deck

Charles H. - Posted: 7/17/2020

Hi Charles, Thank you for leaving such a great review! We are so glad that you enjoyed the awesome location of Called in Sic. We look forward to having you stay with us again!

Prime Vacations staff

Perfect place for our family! The pool area was amazing! Great quiet location! Place had everything you needed! Only downfall was the scare of Covid-19....perfect place for us to quarantine for a week with family! Hope we can stay longer next time! Highly recommend this beautiful home!

Bethany D. - Posted: 4/9/2020

Hi Bethany, we are so glad to hear that you enjoyed our slice of paradise even during scary times. Next time you will definitely have to stay longer! Thanks Bethany!

Prime Vacations staff

Great place for our group of 8. Pool could have been a little warmer, overall it was great!

Cindy R. - Posted: 12/22/2019

Hi CIndy! Thank you for the 5 stars. You can always give us a call during your stay and we can assist with any pool issues or anything else you may need. We are happy to hear you still had a great time!

Prime Vacations staff

We have always stayed on ami and like trying new homes! This one was very nice! Kitchen well stocked, beautiful pool and spa with cool lights! Two minute walk to rod and reel for breakfast and view from the too lookout was gorgeous! Little longer walk to gulf side, about two to three blocks but very short walk to bay side and can walk around to gulf side! Guys did fishing charter twice and had a great time! We will be back! We brought our own pillows to which is always nice! Beds weren’t too bad! Bathrooms large and nice!

Brenda L. - Posted: 8/4/2019

Thank you for all this great feedback Brenda! We really appreciate you taking the time to leave such a great review! We look forward to hopefully having you back in the future!

Prime Vacations staff

First time on Anna Maria island and we loved the location of this house! Great bay and beach access, and the house and pool are so nice. Be sure to check each closet because they all store different items. We found a high chair in one on our third day for our little one! It’s a bit far of a walk to any shops or restaurants (20 minutes) but still doable. We loved the undercover outdoor entertainment area by the pool. Great for families!

Grace S. - Posted: 3/17/2019

Thank you for letting us know about your stay with us at Called in Sic. We're happy to know that you enjoyed your stay and hope to have you stay with us again for your future island getaways!

Prime Vacations staff

We've rented several houses over the years and 'Called in Sic' - by far - is our absolute favorite! We wanted for nothing! The house is beautiful, location is perfect and all the amenities (grill, beach chairs, wagon, umbrella) were in very good shape. The house was tastefully decorated and extremely comfortable. Loved the rooftop deck! We certainly hope to return next year!

Cathy C. - Posted: 12/8/2018

We’re thrilled that you have found your favorite beach home on Anna Maria Island! Thank you so much for letting us know about your stay with us at Called in Sic, we hope to see you again next year!

Prime Vacations staff

Great home, wonderful pool, updated and super clean....wonderful vacation and transaction!!!

Adam N. - Posted: 7/17/2018

Thank you for the review! As a new rental, we are looking for feedback. Hope you get to come back!

Prime Vacations staff